"Which platform should I drive for?"
It's the most common question new drivers ask. And the answer is frustrating: it depends on your city, your vehicle, and your goals.
But here's what we can tell you: the pay structures, the real hourly rates, and which platform works best for different situations.
Quick Comparison
| Factor | Uber Eats | DoorDash | Amazon Flex |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pay structure | Base + tips + surge | Base $2-4 + tips | Fixed rate/block |
| Avg hourly (gross) | $18-25 | $15-22 | $18-25 |
| Avg hourly (net) | $14-20 | $12-18 | $15-22 |
| Flexibility | High | High | Low (scheduled blocks) |
| Vehicle needed | Any (bike OK) | Any (bike OK) | Mid-size car+ |
| Best for | Urban areas | Tip-heavy markets | Consistent income |
Uber Eats: The Flexibility Champion
How Pay Works
Components:
- Base fare (distance + time)
- Customer tips (usually 70-80% of earnings)
- Surge pricing during peak demand
- Quest bonuses (complete X deliveries for bonus)
Real earnings: According to Indeed, Uber Eats drivers in Canada average $16-22/hour gross. After gas and vehicle costs, expect $12-18/hour net.
Pros
- Maximum flexibility — Work whenever, wherever
- Bike/scooter friendly — No car needed in urban areas
- Surge pricing — Can earn $30+/hour during peak
- Good app — Generally reliable navigation
- Instant cashout — Get paid same day
Cons
- Tip dependent — Base pay is low without tips
- Inconsistent — Slow periods can mean $10/hour or less
- No guaranteed hours — Feast or famine
- Wear on vehicle — Lots of short trips
Best For
- Drivers who want complete schedule control
- Urban areas with high tipping culture
- Part-timers who work peak hours only
- Bike/scooter couriers
DoorDash: The Market Share Leader
How Pay Works
Components:
- Base pay: $2-4 per delivery (controversial — very low)
- Customer tips (often 80%+ of total pay)
- Peak pay bonuses
- Challenges and promotions
Real earnings: Ridester reports DoorDash drivers average $15-20/hour gross. Net is closer to $11-16/hour.
Pros
- Largest market share — More orders available
- Order transparency — See pay before accepting
- Peak pay — Predictable bonus periods
- Catering orders — Big tips from business deliveries
Cons
- Lowest base pay — $2-4 base is exploitative
- Tip dependency — Without tips, earnings are terrible
- Declining acceptance rates — Penalized for declining bad orders
- Oversaturation — Many markets have too many drivers
Best For
- Areas with strong tipping culture
- Drivers who can cherry-pick good orders
- Those who want to see pay upfront
- Lunch/dinner rush specialists
Amazon Flex: The Predictable Option
How Pay Works
Components:
- Fixed block rate: $18-25/hour base
- Surge blocks: Up to $35+/hour when demand is high
- Tips (rare — mostly package delivery)
Real earnings: According to Amazon and driver reports, expect $18-25/hour gross. After vehicle costs, $15-22/hour net.
Pros
- Predictable pay — Know exactly what you'll earn
- No tip dependency — Base rate is livable
- Batch efficiency — 30-50 packages per block
- Surge opportunities — High rates when blocks are scarce
- Physical exercise — Walking is good for health
Cons
- Block availability — Hard to get blocks in competitive markets
- Scheduled commitment — Less flexible than food delivery
- Physical demands — Heavy lifting, lots of walking
- Vehicle requirements — Need mid-size car or larger
- Strict timing — Must complete within block window
Best For
- Drivers who prefer predictable income
- Those with larger vehicles
- People who want exercise while working
- Anyone avoiding the tipping lottery
City-by-City Reality
Toronto
| Platform | Market Condition | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| Uber Eats | Saturated but busy | Good for peak hours |
| DoorDash | Very saturated | Only downtown |
| Amazon Flex | Blocks very hard to get | Great if you can get blocks |
Vancouver
| Platform | Market Condition | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| Uber Eats | Strong market | Good overall |
| DoorDash | Competitive | Decent option |
| Amazon Flex | Moderate availability | Worth trying |
Calgary/Edmonton
| Platform | Market Condition | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| Uber Eats | Less saturated | Often best option |
| DoorDash | Growing | Getting competitive |
| Amazon Flex | Good availability | Reliable income |
The Multi-Platform Strategy
Here's what top earners actually do:
They don't choose one platform. They use all of them.
Why Multi-Platform Works
- Fill slow periods — When Uber is slow, DoorDash might be busy
- Catch surges — Monitor multiple apps for peak pricing
- Combine deliveries — Food + packages in one route
- Flexibility + stability — Flex blocks for base income, food apps for extra
The Challenge
Managing multiple platforms is chaos:
- Different apps, different interfaces
- Hard to optimize routes across platforms
- Easy to accept conflicting orders
- Mental load of constant switching
The Solution: FlexMesh
FlexMesh unifies your multi-platform chaos:
- Scan any waybill — Amazon, Intelcom, UPS, FedEx
- Add food delivery addresses — From any app
- One optimized route — AI combines all stops
- Works with everything — Not platform-specific
Example:
- You have 30 Amazon Flex packages
- You accept 2 Uber Eats orders along the route
- FlexMesh shows you exactly where to insert them
- One efficient route instead of juggling apps
Making Your Decision
Choose Uber Eats If:
- You want maximum flexibility
- You're in an urban area with good tips
- You don't have a large vehicle
- You want to work when you want
Choose DoorDash If:
- Your area has strong tipping culture
- You want to see pay before accepting
- You can handle declining low-pay orders
- Uber Eats isn't available in your area
Choose Amazon Flex If:
- You want predictable income
- You have a mid-size or larger vehicle
- You don't mind physical work
- Block availability is good in your area
Choose All Three If:
- You want to maximize earnings
- You're willing to manage complexity
- You'll use FlexMesh to stay organized
- You want flexibility AND stability
Bottom Line
There is no "best" platform. There's only the best platform for YOUR situation.
- For flexibility: Uber Eats
- For market access: DoorDash
- For predictability: Amazon Flex
- For maximum earnings: All three with FlexMesh
The drivers earning $25+/hour aren't loyal to one platform. They're strategic, they're multi-platform, and they use tools like FlexMesh to make it work.
Sources:
Join Discord Community